Sig P229 vs P365: Which One Should I Choose?

Firearm Reviews & Recommendations
1

I’ve been doing a lot of thinking about choosing between the SIG P229 and the P365. Both are highly regarded in the firearm community, but I find myself stuck trying to figure out which would be the best fit for my needs. To help me make a decision, I’m hoping to get insights from fellow enthusiasts.

Specifications Overview

  • SIG P229: Known for being a classic in the firearms world, the P229 is larger, heavier, and often considered a more reliable option for accuracy in shooting.
  • SIG P365: On the other hand, the P365 is a newer model that has gained a tremendous following due to its compact size and capacity. It’s touted as an excellent everyday carry gun.

Key Comparisons

  1. Size and Weight
    The P229 is bulkier and heavier, making it potentially less desirable for carry purposes, while the P365’s compact design allows for easier concealment.

  2. Accuracy and Performance
    The P229 offers a bit more stability and accuracy with its weight, but I’ve read that the P365 holds its own surprisingly well, even in rapid fire.

  3. Carryability
    The question I have is: for day-to-day carrying, how does the weight and grip feel when carrying the P365 vs. the P229? Is the P365 really that much more comfortable?

  4. User Experiences
    I’m also curious to hear about your personal experiences. How have they performed in different conditions? Any thoughts on durability?

Looking for Input

For those who have experience with both models, what do you think? Did you choose one over the other? Why? Are there specific scenarios where one excels compared to the other?

Anything else I should know before making a purchase?

Thanks in advance for your help!

2

The SIG P229 has a barrel length of 3.9 inches, while the P365 is 3.1 inches. This difference can affect accuracy at longer ranges.

3

That’s right! The P229 feels more solid in hand, but the P365 is great for concealed carry due to its smaller size.

8 Likes
4

What about the weight? The P229 is heavier at about 34 oz, which helps with recoil but isn’t the best for all-day carry.

8 Likes
5

I agree! The weight is a significant factor. The P365’s weight is around 17.8 oz, making it much more comfortable for everyday carry.

6

The magazine capacity is another key difference. The P229 typically holds 15 rounds, while the P365 can offer 10+1 to 12+1 depending on the magazine. More rounds can mean less reloading!

7

That’s a solid point! In a defensive situation, having more rounds can definitely make a difference.

1 Like
8

Both have their pros and cons. I love the feel of the P229 but can see the P365 being better for agility and speed, especially for everyday carry.

9

Totally agree! Plus, the compact design of the P365 allows for easier storage.

8 Likes
10

I’m curious about how the trigger action feels on both. I read that the P365 has a lighter trigger pull.

4 Likes
11

Yes! The P365’s trigger is smoother. It could lead to better accuracy for some shooters.

12

I really appreciate all this info! I’m leaning towards the P365 for its size but love the P229’s capabilities.

13

That’s a solid choice! Just remember, personal preference plays a huge role in this decision. Try both at a range if you can!

6 Likes
14

At the end of the day, if you can afford it, maybe get both! Wouldn’t hurt to have options, right? Plus, the P229 can be your truck gun.

15

I’m really torn between the P229 and the P365! The P229 feels great in my hand, but I’m curious about the P365’s compactness for everyday carry. Anyone have thoughts on grip size?

16

The P365 is super comfortable for concealed carry. I barely notice it when I’m wearing it, but the grip is definitely smaller than the P229. For my hands, the P229 feels more natural.

17

I agree with Nicholas! I have both, and while the P229 has that classic Sig feel, the P365 excels with its trigger. It’s smooth and makes shooting faster. What do you guys think about the trigger feel?

18

The trigger on the P229 is a bit heavier but I actually love the feedback. It feels more solid during the pull. Just my preference!

19

That’s interesting, Dblair! I’ve always thought a lighter trigger helps with precision shooting, especially in the P365. But I do get the appeal of a solid pull in the P229, which gives more control.

20

I really like how the P365 has a flatter profile; it feels really nice during shooting sessions. Anyone else find it more enjoyable to shoot over longer periods?