P365 vs M&P Shield: Which is the Better Everyday Carry?

Firearm Reviews & Recommendations
1

Introduction

In the world of concealed carry pistols, the Sig P365 and the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield have made quite a name for themselves. Both have their strengths and weaknesses, and as someone looking to choose my next everyday carry firearm, I’ve found myself pondering which one truly stands out. I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences on these two models!

Specifications

Let’s start by looking at the basic specs of both:

  • Sig P365

    • Caliber: 9mm
    • Capacity: 10+1 (12+1 with extended magazine)
    • Weight: Approximately 17.8 oz (unloaded)
    • Overall Length: 5.8 inches

  • Smith & Wesson M&P Shield

    • Caliber: 9mm / .40 S&W
    • Capacity: 7+1 / 8+1 (depending on model)
    • Weight: Approximately 20.8 oz (unloaded)
    • Overall Length: 6.1 inches

Performance

Accuracy

From what I’ve gathered, both pistols are known for their accuracy at typical self-defense ranges. The P365 has been praised for its precise trigger and sight options, while the M&P Shield owners often highlight how comfortable it feels to shoot, even for extended sessions.

Recoil Management

The P365’s lower weight might induce greater recoil, but many users report that its design helps mitigate this. On the other hand, the M&P Shield, being slightly heavier, may absorb recoil better, which is something to consider during practice sessions.

Comfort & Ergonomics

This is quite subjective, but I’m curious about how each model feels in hand. I’ve noticed that some people find the P365 grip to be more comfortable and easier to control, while others prefer the flatter profile of the M&P Shield, especially when carrying concealed.

Concealed Carry

How do you all feel about the size differences? The P365 is often lauded for its compactness, making it a great choice for concealed carry. The M&P Shield, being a bit longer, sometimes requires different holster options, which could influence your daily carry setup.

Features

Sights

The sights on both models come with options, but which do you prefer? The P365 often features night sights, while the Shield can come with both standard and upgraded options depending on the model you choose.

Safety Features

The Shield offers a manual safety option, which is a huge plus for some users. The P365, however, does not include a manual safety but is designed with a striker-fired trigger system that some find equally safe.

Conclusion

So, based on all the above comparisons, which one would you recommend for someone considering a new concealed carry? Any specific experiences or suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
Let’s get a discussion going!

2

I’ve had my P365 for a while now, and its reliability is top-notch. I took it through rain and mud, and it still performed flawlessly. Plus, that double-stack magazine gives you a great capacity without sacrificing size.

3

That’s great to hear, wmurphy! I’ve been considering the M&P Shield, but I’ve read mixed reviews about its feed issues. Any thoughts?

1 Like
4

The Shield has been my go-to carry for years. I’ve put hundreds of rounds through it, and I’ve encountered issues with certain ammo types. It’s generally reliable, but I always stick to tested brands.

8 Likes
5

Good point, swhite! I wonder if the P365 handles a wider variety of ammo without issues? Anyone had any unusual experiences?

6

My P365 has been a champ. I’ve tested it in sub-zero temperatures and in the heat of summer, and it’s always run like a dream. However, I do clean it regularly to keep it that way.

5 Likes
7

That’s impressive! I’ve always been curious about how the Shield performs in varied weather. Anyone had issues with it in extreme climates?

8

I personally find the Shield a bit more comfortable to carry. It fits perfectly in my hand, but I must admit, the P365 has slightly better capacity, which is a big plus for daily carry.

9

I agree! Comfort is essential. However, I wonder if that translates into better accuracy for the Shield? Any takers on shooting comparisons?

4 Likes
10

I shot both back-to-back at the range. The P365 felt a bit snappier but allowed for quick follow-ups, while the Shield was more stable but slower on the recovery. Depends on what you prioritize.

11

Interesting take, john92! For everyday use, how would you rate your reliability on both? Maybe a scale of 1-10?

12

I’d give the P365 a solid 9 for reliability and the Shield a 7. Both are good, but the P365 just edges it out for me, especially in tough conditions.

7 Likes
13

That’s some solid scoring, tiffany05! I’m kind of leaning towards the P365 now, but I worry about how it handles extended shooting sessions. Any fatigue issues?

14

For extended sessions, the P365’s grip is a little smaller, so it can become tiring after a while. But, nothing an extra grip sleeve can’t fix, right? Haha!

15

I’ve handled both the P365 and the M&P Shield. For me, the P365 has a better grip feel, particularly for smaller hands. The weight is also a plus for concealed carry, making it less cumbersome during long days.

16

I totally agree! The Shield can feel a bit heavier after a while. It’s surprising how much that matters when you’re carrying all day.

17

The M&P Shield has a solid feel to it, but I find the trigger a bit stiff. The P365’s trigger is more responsive, which I appreciate for quick follow-up shots.

18

That’s interesting! I didn’t notice the trigger much, but the grip on the Shield felt really secure to me. No slipping even with sweat.

1 Like
19

I prefer the P365 for extended use. It’s just lighter overall. Have you guys noticed how less fatigue you feel after a long day carrying it around?

20

Exactly! I was caught off guard by how tiring the Shield was on a few long days at the range. The P365 definitely wins in that aspect.