I’ve been doing some research on handguns, and I keep coming across debates between the Glock 19X and Glock 17. Both models seem to have their pros and cons, and I’m hoping to gather some insights from people who might own one or both.
Performance Comparison
I understand that the Glock 19X is a crossover with a 19 slide on a 17 frame, which theoretically provides a better grip and more magazine capacity. However, I’ve read that the Glock 17 is renowned for its accuracy and reliability due to its longer barrel.
Accuracy: How does the accuracy compare between the two? Is one model noticeably better for target shooting?
Concealment and Carrying
I’m particularly interested in concealed carry. The Glock 19X seems like it would be better suited for that given its design, but I often hear that the Glock 17 isn’t too cumbersome either.
What are your experiences? If you’ve carried either of these for self-defense purposes, how do they stack up in terms of comfort and concealability?
Size and Weight
Another aspect I’m curious about is the size difference. The 19X is just slightly shorter in both length and height, but how does that translate into real-world handling?
Weight: Does the difference in weight make a noticeable impact during prolonged carry?
Intended Use
Lastly, I would love to hear your thoughts on the suitability of each model for home defense versus regular range shooting. I’m trying to figure out if one might be better for home defense purposes while the other could serve as a reliable range gun.
Home Defense vs Range: Which model do you think is better suited for home defense, and why?
I appreciate any insights you all can share about your experiences with these models. Any recommendations or considerations I should keep in mind while making a decision would be extremely helpful! Thanks in advance for your help!
I’ve owned both the Glock 19X and the Glock 17. The 19X has a shorter barrel and is a bit more compact, making it easier to conceal. This is a big plus for personal defense situations.
I appreciate both models for different reasons. The Glock 17 is often preferred in law enforcement for its accuracy over longer distances due to that longer barrel.
I find the Glock 19X aesthetically more appealing. It just looks awesome with that flat darker finish. But looks aside, it’s really about functionality!
The grip on the Glock 19X can feel a bit bulkier due to the integrated lanyard loop. It might not be for everyone, but it feels great for my hands. Comfort is key in a defense situation!
Just a thought! Some might say the Glock 19X is more versatile for everyday carry scenarios, while the 17 shines in target shooting. Anyone else notice how the balance differs?
Honestly, I’ve got to be a bit contentious here—while both are great, the Glock 17 has always had a stronger reputation for reliability in high-stress law enforcement situations.
I’ve owned both the Glock 19X and Glock 17. The 19X feels great in hand due to its unique grip texture. However, I find the weight distribution of the Glock 17 a bit more balanced when shooting long sessions at the range.
I actually prefer the Glock 17. It feels solid, and after several rounds, I never get fatigued. The 19X can feel a bit front-heavy for some shooters, depending on how you hold it.
I tried both at a shop. I liked the 19X’s shape, but the 17 just felt more reliable for extended use. Ultimately, it’s about what works best for you! Anyone else feel the same?
I’ve read that people find the 19X easier to handle for quick follow-up shots. If you’re looking for a performance piece, the shorter barrel of the 19X might suit you better.