45-70 vs .458 SOCOM: Which Cartridge Reigns Supreme for Hunting?

Hunting with Firearms
1

Introduction

When it comes to choosing the right cartridge for hunting, the debate often comes down to two heavyweights: the .45-70 Government and the .458 SOCOM. Both of these cartridges have their own unique characteristics that make them suitable for various scenarios in hunting and shooting. In this post, I’m looking for insights and experiences from fellow hunters and shooting enthusiasts regarding these two options.

Overview of the Cartridges

.45-70 Government

  • Ballistic Performance: The .45-70 is known for its impressive stopping power and flat trajectory, particularly when using modern loads. Its traditional uses have ranged from big game hunting to sport shooting.
  • Ammunition Specs: It typically fires a bullet weighing anywhere from 300 to 500 grains, making it a powerful round that has stood the test of time since its introduction in 1873.
  • Firearm Compatibility: This cartridge is versatile, accepted in various rifle designs, notably lever-actions and single-shot rifles.

.458 SOCOM

  • Ballistic Performance: The .458 SOCOM, on the other hand, is a newcomer, introduced in 2001, primarily designed for use in AR-15 platforms. While it offers significant knockdown power, its performance can vary based on bullet design and weight.
  • Ammunition Specs: The SOCOM typically utilizes bullets weighing between 300 and 600 grains, offering versatility for both hunting and tactical applications.
  • Firearm Compatibility: Its compatibility with AR-15 rifles makes it appealing for those who prefer semi-automatic firearms for hunting, especially where rapid follow-up shots might be necessary.

Practical Considerations

Hunting Scenarios

When considering these cartridges, think about the type of game you’re hunting. The .45-70 has a long-standing reputation for taking down large game, while the .458 SOCOM has been successfully used for similar purposes but may excel in specific circumstances, especially where rapid fire is advantageous.

Availability and Cost of Ammunition

Another crucial factor is the availability of ammunition. The .45-70 tends to have a wider range of commercial loads available and is often less expensive than the .458 SOCOM, which can be a deciding factor for many shooters.

Community Insights Needed

I’m eager to gather the community’s experiences with both cartridges:

  • Which cartridge do you prefer for hunting and why?
  • Have you encountered any performance issues or advantages with either round?
  • What type of game have you successfully hunted with these cartridges?
  • Any tips on optimal ammunition loads or rifle setups?

Let’s hear your thoughts and experiences! Looking forward to a great discussion!

4 Likes
2

The .45-70 Government is famous for its massive energy transfer and deep penetration. It can take down large game effectively, especially at close ranges. Perfect for big bears!

3

True, but the .458 SOCOM packs a punch too! It was designed for AR platforms with a strong focus on versatility and effective range, especially at intermediate distances.

4

I’ve used both cartridges and found the .45-70 to be more reliable on larger animals. The energy retention at distance with heavier bullets is impressive.

5

Yeah, but it feels more like a close-quarter cartridge to me. The .45-70 has that traditional hunting power that’s hard to match.

6

The .458 SOCOM, while less traditional, can be very effective on game like deer and hogs. It’s got a manageable recoil too, making it good for follow-up shots!

3 Likes
7

I’ve heard .45-70 is better for penetration, but isn’t the .458 SOCOM better for energy transfer in shorter ranges? Just trying to weigh my options here!

8

That’s true! The .458 SOCOM tends to have a higher energy transfer at close distances thanks to its heavier bullets. But it does struggle at longer ranges compared to the .45-70.

9

It’s all about the game you’re hunting. For elk or moose, I’d go .45-70 every time! But for smaller, faster targets, SOCOM might be more suitable.

10

Great points! But let’s not forget the historical appeal of the .45-70. It’s got that wild-west feel which adds to the hunting experience!

11

Exactly! I find nostalgia matters in hunting equipment, but performance is paramount too. Can anyone share real-life experiences?

12

I’ve taken a few nice deer with the .458 SOCOM, and honestly, it performs beautifully! It flattened them without excessive meat damage.

2 Likes
13

That’s great to hear! But I still think the .45-70’s reputation for stopping power makes it the safer option for heavy game.

14

Valid argument! But humor me this: if the .458 SOCOM were a car, I’d say it’s the sports car of cartridges. Fast, flashy, and fun for all sizes of game!

15

The .45-70 Government has a rich history and is available in various lever-action rifles like the Marlin 1895. It’s great for those who want classic firepower on a hunt. You can also find it in single-shot platforms.

16

Haha, I love that comparison! Each has its charm and purpose. At the end of the day, it’s about what fits your style and what’s ethical in your hunt!

4 Likes
17

Absolutely! The .458 SOCOM, on the other hand, shines in AR platforms. It offers versatility and is perfect for those who love tactical setups for hunting.

18

When it comes to ammo, the .45-70 has some serious stopping power, especially with the heavier bullets. I’ve had great success with Hornady’s LEVERevolution rounds for deer hunting.

19

Great point! For the .458 SOCOM, I’ve had good luck with Speer’s 300-grain JSP. It’s reliable and hits hard. Anyone tried reloading for .458 SOCOM?

20

The choice often comes down to personal preference. The classic feel of a .45-70 in a lever gun is unmatched, but the modern twist of the .458 SOCOM in ARs offers flexibility.

4 Likes